Our Rooms

Home » Our Rooms

The Niceties

We are “bed serious” about a good night’s sleep at the Cracked Mug.   So we have hand-picked each and every item for your nighttime rest.

You’ll sleep between the softest-ever eucalyptus sheets (eucalyptus is the “new” Egyptian cotton, they say), provided by Sheets & Giggles.

You’ll snuggle under premium down comforter duvets.

And because everyone has their own idea of the perfect pillow, we’ve created a “pillow menu” so you can choose between goose down filling, memory foam, or maybe aromatic chamomile or lavender.


The 3 rooms

Come stay with us at the Cracked Mug in one of our 3 guestrooms, each named after one of my sons.

Two are Waterview:  The Anthony and the Alexander.

Both have Queen beds, and views overlooking the Monhegan harbor, the isle of Manana, and Muscongus Bay.

One is Partial Oceanview:  The Bradley

The Bradley has a 2 twin beds with a trundle, and looks out its southern window towards the Atlantic Ocean, and out the other window to the church

All rooms share a full bath in the hallway, as well as a ½ bath downstairs, and our brand new waterview outdoor shower!

*2021 Rates for Two Guests:

$180/night including 5* breaakfast
3rd guest surcharge:  $30/night



Guesthouse life

The deck…

Our broad deck with panoramic views of the harbor is surely one of the highlights of the Cracked Mug.

It’s the place to hang out with your breakfast plate, with a blanket for an afternoon snooze in the sun, or with your favorite drink for evening Sundowners.

We want you to make yourself at home, with some of the best private deck views on the island!

The kitchen…

The kitchen is the heart of our home at the Cracked Mug.  We are big foodies (my friends will tell you that my if it doesn’t walk off my plate, I eat it!).

So if you like food, then you’ve come to the right place.

We are dedicated to your gastronomic delight on the island, starting with our Signature Sweet -my Mother’s French Coffee Cake.  You can count on a robust breakfast, plus extra services like packed-for-you picnics with our CM* Smoked Salmon.  Go here to read more about the Cracked Mug Kitchen.

Settle in…

  • Choose a game:  Monhegan puzzles, Vertelis (a Dutch conversation-starter card game), Cuban dominoes, and even our own one-of-a-kind Mohnopoly.
  • Spin some vinyl.
  • Paint a rock for our Kindness Rock Project: https://www.thekindnessrocksproject.com/
  • Let us connect you with locals for special island experiences.
  • Do sunrise yoga on the deck.
  • Attend one of our Destination Nights (led by your innkeeper, Rare Finds Travel Design CEO Melanie Tucker)
  • And more!

WiFi is available in the house (as long as the fog doesn’t roll in) but we hope you’ll lock your devices in the CellPhone Lockbox and really take this chance to unwind.


Cracked Mug Policies


  • Help us spread love in this world by painting a rock for the Kindness Rock Project (materials provided at the house).
  • Bring photos of your furchildren to show us, but leave them safely at home.
  • Cancel at least 21 days before your stay (otherwise we can only refund if we can rebook)*
  • Give yourself a tech-free visit by keeping your phones and laptops in your room (or better yet, in that Lockbox)
  • Refrain from smoking.
  • Let us know what you need.  Because we are here to help!

*No charge for your arrival night if weather cancels ferries and you can’t get here.